This post may contain affiliate links. If you book or buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
The garden is down to nothing right now. Everything is cut back or mulched over, the beds are flat brown rectangles, and from the kitchen window it looks like we never grew a thing out there. This is my favorite time of year to work on it.
Cottage garden planning happens in November for me, not in May. In May I am standing in a nursery making decisions with my heart because something is blooming in front of me and I want it in my car. In November there is nothing blooming anywhere and I can see the actual shape of the yard. No leaves, no growth, nothing covering up last year’s mistakes. I can walk the back of our property in Long Grove with a cold cup of coffee and see exactly where a bed is too narrow and where the path should have gone in the first place.

What a cottage garden actually is
It is density and informality. Plants close together, spilling over the edges, flowers and food and herbs mixed in the same bed instead of sorted into separate zones. Curved or straight is fine. Tidy is not really the point.
What it is not is a shopping list. You cannot buy a cottage garden in one spring, and the photos that made you want one are almost always year five or six of somebody’s work. That gap is the thing I wish I had understood earlier, because it is the reason so many people decide they failed when actually they were just early.
Why November is the right month to do this
The bones are visible. With everything dormant you can see grade, drainage, where water sits, where the house casts shade in the afternoon. In July all of that is hidden under growth.
Winter is also when the ordering windows open. Bare root roses, perennial divisions and a lot of the better seed sell out in January and February, so a plan made in November is a plan you can actually act on instead of taking whatever is left at the garden center in May.
And honestly, it costs nothing. A sketch is free. I have an autoimmune disease and some seasons I have a lot less in the tank than I want to, so doing the thinking part in the months when I am inside anyway means the spring work is just execution. I am not also trying to design it while hauling soil.
I start with paths, not plants
This is the part most cottage garden advice skips straight past, and it is the part that decides whether you use the garden or just look at it.
Draw the paths first. A main path needs to be wide enough for two people to pass or for a wheelbarrow with somebody walking beside it, which in practice is about three to four feet. Anything narrower and the plants flop over it by July and you stop walking through. Secondary paths can be eighteen inches to two feet.
Then the beds. Nothing deeper than about four feet if you can reach it from both sides, nothing deeper than about three if it sits against a fence. I have built beds I could not reach the middle of, and what grows in the middle of a bed you cannot reach is weeds. Most of what I learned about this came out of planning our vegetable beds, and I wrote the dimensions down properly in my beginner vegetable garden layout.
If you are starting from lawn, you do not have to dig any of it. Cardboard down now, mulch on top, and the grass is gone by spring. That is the whole method in how to start a garden from scratch, and November is the correct time to put it down.

Year one looks sparse, and that is not your fault
Perennials sleep, creep, then leap. First year they put everything into roots and sulk. Second year they fill out. Third year they finally look like the picture.
So year one, I plant annuals in every gap. Zinnias, cosmos, calendula, nasturtiums. They are cheap, they grow from a packet of seed sown directly in the ground, and they do the job of looking like a cottage garden while the actual cottage garden is underground growing roots. The year I stopped apologizing for a sparse bed and just filled it with zinnias was the year the whole thing started being fun.
What holds up here
We are zone 5b, which means cold winters, a hot stretch in July, and wind. A lot of the classic English cottage planting lists were written for a much gentler climate than this one.
What earns its place in our beds: peonies, catmint, salvia, baptisia, coneflower, black-eyed Susan, yarrow, garden phlox, daylilies, bearded iris, and hollyhocks along anything vertical. Foxglove is worth growing but know going in that most of them are biennial, so they make leaves one year and flower the next. Plant them two years running and then you have them every year.
Deer are a fact of life out here. I plan around it rather than fighting it, which mostly means the things deer leave alone (catmint, salvia, yarrow, anything fuzzy or strongly scented) go on the outside edges, and the things they love go closest to the house. More of what grows well in this climate is in what to grow in a Midwest garden.
Bulbs belong in this plan too, and they are the one thing you cannot put off, because they go in the ground before it freezes. If you missed that window this year, you can still force some bulbs indoors and get flowers in the house by late winter.

What I would skip
Delphiniums. They are on every cottage garden list ever written and they are genuinely beautiful, and in an open Midwest yard they are a staking project that ends with a six foot flower spike snapped over in a thunderstorm in June. If you have a sheltered spot against a wall, try them. If your yard is open, there are better uses of that space.
I would also skip planting the whole thing in one season. Not because of the money, though that adds up faster than you expect, but because you learn the yard by growing in it. The bed I planned two years ago is not the bed I would plan today, and I only know that because I spent two summers walking past it.
And skip paying for perennials you can get free. Most perennials want dividing every few years, which means every gardener you know has clumps of something they are about to throw away in April. Ask. People are weirdly thrilled to be asked.
How I actually sketch it
Graph paper, one square equals one foot. Measure the space with a long tape, mark the fixed things first (house, fence, trees, spigot, anything you cannot move), then the paths, then the beds. Plants last, and in pencil, because the plants are the part that changes.
Then I go outside and lay it out at full size with marking flags and a length of rope for the path edges, and I leave it there for a week. Beds always look smaller on paper than they feel in the yard. Walking it is how I catch that. Danny thinks the flags are excessive. Danny has also never had to move a peony.
🛒 A few things I use for this
- A graph paper notebook, one square to one foot
- Garden marking flags for laying beds out at full size
- A long open reel tape measure, much easier than a short one for this
- Annual seed for year one, zinnias and cosmos and calendula
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The sketch on my kitchen table right now is mostly wrong. It always is. I will find out which parts in June, and then I will redraw it next November with better information.
That is the actual pleasure of it. Not the finished garden. The part where it is still all ahead of you.