From-Scratch Freezer Meals: What I Actually Keep in Mine

This post may contain affiliate links. If you book or buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

I keep a small chest freezer in the back hall of the farmhouse, and for a long time it held exactly two things: a bag of frozen peas and whatever Danny bought in bulk and forgot about. That changed the winter after Lochlan was born, when I finally understood that a full freezer is not about being organized. It is about having a plan for the nights when you have nothing left. From-scratch freezer meals are the only reason we eat real food on the days I can barely stand at the stove.

I want to be honest about what this actually looks like, because most of what comes up when you search for this is a list of thirty recipes and a photo of a freezer that looks like a grocery store. Mine does not look like that. I keep about six things in rotation, I have stopped freezing several things that came out badly, and I do the whole thing in one afternoon every few weeks instead of a marathon cook day.

What’s in my freezer right now

Here is the actual inventory, end of September, no editing:

• Four quarts of chicken noodle soup base. Broth, chicken, carrots, celery, onion. No noodles. (More on that below.)
• Six pints of bone broth. This is the backbone of everything else I make. My homemade bone broth method takes almost no active time, and I freeze it in pint jars so I can pull exactly what a recipe needs.
• Three quarts of butternut squash soup. Made from the squash that came out of the garden in August.
• Two trays of meatballs, frozen raw. Beef, egg, sourdough breadcrumbs, parmesan, garlic.
• Five bags of garden tomato sauce. The tail end of a very good tomato year.
• Two pans of shepherd’s pie, assembled and unbaked. This is the one that saves us most often.
• A dozen sourdough English muffins and a quart bag of cooked, seasoned ground beef for tacos.

That is it. Seven or eight things, most of them made from something I was already cooking. I am not batch cooking new recipes for the freezer. I am cooking double and putting half away, which is a completely different amount of work.

What freezes well, and what I stopped freezing

This is the part nobody tells you, and it cost me a lot of wasted food to learn.

Freezes beautifully: anything soup or stew based, as long as it is broth-heavy rather than cream-heavy. Tomato sauce. Raw meatballs and raw burger patties. Cooked seasoned ground meat. Assembled casseroles that have not been baked yet. Bread dough, biscuit dough, pie crust. Cooked beans in their liquid. Pesto in ice cube trays.

Does not freeze well, and I have given up trying:

Noodles and rice in soup. They come out of the freezer swollen and mealy, and they drink all the broth while they sit. I freeze the soup base and boil noodles fresh in five minutes when I reheat it. This one change made my from-scratch chicken noodle soup actually worth freezing.

Anything finished with dairy. Cream and milk break when they thaw and you get a grainy, separated mess. I freeze the squash soup without cream on purpose and stir in what I want at the end. Same with potato soup.

Baked potatoes and raw potato chunks. They go gritty and slightly sweet. In shepherd’s pie the mashed topping is fine because it has enough fat in it, but a stew full of cubed potatoes is not fine. I add potatoes when I reheat.

Fried anything. It never comes back crisp. I stopped pretending it would.

Lettuce, cucumber, fresh herbs as garnish. Obvious in hindsight. I still did it once.

Knowing this list is more useful than knowing thirty recipes, because it means you can look at almost anything you already cook and correctly guess whether it belongs in the freezer.

How I actually get it done, without wrecking myself

I have an autoimmune disease, which means a twelve-hour cook day is not something I can trade for a stocked freezer. If I spend a Saturday standing up, I lose Sunday and probably Monday. So the freezer gets filled in small pieces instead.

The way it works here:

I cook double, almost always. If I am making soup, I make twice as much and one half never hits the table. This costs me zero extra effort beyond a bigger pot and about ten more minutes of chopping. It is the single most effective thing I do.

One two-hour afternoon every two or three weeks. Not a whole day. I pick two things, usually one soup and one assembled casserole, and I sit on a stool at the counter to do the prep. Lochlan naps for one of those hours and plays on the kitchen floor with Dewey for the other. Delilah supervises from the windowsill, which is her only job.

I prep in the order that lets things overlap. Broth or soup on the stove first, because it can be ignored. Meat browning next. Chopping while those go. Assembly last, when everything is cool enough to handle. The whole thing has a rhythm now and I barely think about it.

I stop when I am tired, not when I am finished. If I get one thing into the freezer instead of two, that is one dinner I do not have to cook later. There is no version of this where a half-finished afternoon was a waste. My from-scratch meal prep approach on low-energy days works the same way, and it took me a long time to stop treating rest as the thing I do after I have earned it.

Packing, labeling, and pulling dinner out at five o’clock

A freezer full of unlabeled bricks is not a stocked freezer. It is a guessing game, and at five o’clock with a hungry toddler I am not playing.

Portion to how you actually eat. We are two adults and a toddler who eats off our plates. Quart containers are a dinner for us. Pints are a lunch or a component. I stopped freezing anything in gallon bags because a gallon of soup takes all day to thaw and then we eat it for four days.

Freeze liquids flat, then stack. Soup and sauce go into freezer bags, laid flat on a sheet pan until solid, then filed upright like books. This tripled what fits in my chest freezer. For the things I want in glass, wide-mouth jars only, filled with an inch of headspace so they do not crack.

Label with the date and what to do with it. Not just “chicken soup.” I write “chicken soup base, add noodles, 10/2” with a grease pencil. Six weeks from now I will not remember that the noodles are missing, and that is exactly how good food goes to waste.

Thaw in the fridge the night before. I have a standing habit of looking at the freezer while I make Lochlan’s breakfast and moving one thing down to the fridge. Thirty seconds. It is the whole trick. Soups and unbaked casseroles can go in frozen if I forget, they just need a much longer, lower oven.

Three months is my real limit. Things keep longer than that, technically, but the quality drops and I would rather eat it while it is good. I do a quick sweep of the freezer at the start of each season, which is also when I find the apple pie filling I put up in September and remember to bake something with it.

There is a particular kind of relief in opening that freezer on a bad evening and finding a pan of shepherd’s pie with my own handwriting on the foil. Nothing about it is impressive. It is just me, three weeks ago, deciding to be kind to me now.

If you are starting from an empty freezer, pick one soup. Make it double. That is the whole beginning.