Homemade Applesauce Recipe (No Sugar, Big Batch, Freezes All Winter)

This post may contain affiliate links. If you book or buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Every September our kitchen counter stops being a counter and turns into a staging area for apples. That is just what happens here. Danny brings home more than we planned for, I say we will get through them, and then I spend an afternoon standing at the stove with a pot that barely fits on the burner. This homemade applesauce recipe is what comes out of that afternoon, and it is the most useful thing I make all fall.

It is not a five minute recipe. I know that is what most of the internet promises. Mine takes the better part of an afternoon from the first quartered apple to the last container in the freezer, and I would rather tell you that now than have you standing in your kitchen at eight at night wondering what went wrong. What you get for the afternoon is a whole winter of applesauce with nothing in it but apples.

Lochlan eats it almost every day. That is the real reason there is no sugar in mine.

The short version

Quarter your apples. Do not peel them if you own a food mill. Put them in a heavy pot with a small splash of water and a squeeze of lemon, put the lid on, and cook them over medium low heat until they collapse, about thirty minutes. Run the whole thing through a food mill, or peel and core first and mash by hand. Taste it before you reach for sugar, because most of the time you will not need any. Cool it completely and freeze it in portions.

That is the whole thing. Everything below is the detail I wish someone had given me the first year I tried this.

The apples I use, and why I never use just one kind

This is the part that matters most and the part almost nobody explains. Applesauce made from one variety of apple tastes flat. Applesauce made from three tastes like applesauce.

I aim for a mix of something that breaks down, something tart, and something sweet.

Something that breaks down: McIntosh, Cortland, or Gala. These fall apart into sauce almost on their own, which does most of the work for you. If I could only pick one apple, it would be McIntosh.

Something tart: Granny Smith or Jonathan. Without a tart apple in the pot the sauce goes cloying and one note. A third of the batch is usually tart.

Something sweet: Honeycrisp, Fuji, or whatever the orchard has too many of. This is what lets you skip sugar entirely. The sweetness is already in the fruit, you just have to put it there on purpose.

Five pounds of apples makes roughly six cups of sauce. I never make five pounds. I make fifteen or twenty at a time because the pot is already dirty and the afternoon is already spent.

How I actually make it

You need a big heavy pot. I use the same enameled dutch oven I make garden tomato sauce in every August, which by September has basically become the seasonal preserving pot.

1. Wash and quarter the apples. Skins on, cores in, stems out. If you have a food mill, that is genuinely all the prep there is. If you do not, peel and core them now and accept that this is the long part.
2. Add liquid, barely. Half a cup of water for five pounds of apples, and the juice of half a lemon. The apples release a shocking amount of their own liquid. More water is the single most common reason homemade applesauce turns out thin and sad.
3. Lid on, medium low. Stir every ten minutes or so and scrape the bottom. You are looking for the apples to lose their shape completely, which takes twenty five to forty minutes depending on the variety and how thick you cut them.
4. Mill or mash. A food mill takes the skins and seeds out and leaves the color and pectin in, which is why milled sauce comes out that soft pink instead of beige. If you peeled ahead of time, a potato masher gives you chunky and an immersion blender gives you smooth. I do half and half, chunky for us and smooth for Lochlan.
5. Taste before you sweeten. Nine times out of ten a good apple mix does not need anything. If it does, a spoonful of maple syrup stirred in at the end is enough.

Cinnamon is optional and I am inconsistent about it. Some batches get a cinnamon stick dropped in while it cooks. Some stay plain, because plain is what a nineteen month old actually wants and because plain is more useful later when I am baking with it.

Freezing it, and how long it actually keeps

Freezing is the whole point for me. I do not can. Canning is a beautiful skill and I admire the people who do it well, but with an autoimmune disease I have to be honest with myself about which projects are worth the energy I have, and a water bath canner running for hours in a warm kitchen has never made that list. The freezer does the same job for me with a fraction of the effort.

In the fridge, homemade applesauce keeps about seven to ten days in a clean sealed jar. In the freezer it holds its flavor for a good twelve months, and I have eaten sixteen month old sauce in February with no complaints from anyone.

Two things I have learned the hard way. Cool it completely before it goes in the freezer, because warm sauce in a sealed jar makes ice crystals and the texture goes grainy. And leave an inch of headspace, because it expands and a cracked jar in the freezer is a genuinely annoying mess to find.

I freeze it three ways. Pint jars for us, silicone cubes for Lochlan, and a couple of quart containers set aside specifically for baking, because applesauce is one of the easiest things to have on hand when you want to make something quickly and you did not plan ahead. It goes in oatmeal, it goes in muffins, it goes into the pork we eat on cold nights. If you are working on making more of your food from scratch without adding hours to your week, this is the same logic behind my from scratch meal prep on low energy days.

What I would skip, and what I got wrong

The first fall I did this, I peeled and cored every single apple by hand. All twenty pounds. It took most of a day, my hands hurt for two days afterward, and the sauce was not better for it. It was worse, actually, because the skins are where a lot of the color and the pectin live. If you are going to make applesauce more than once, get the food mill. That is the one thing I would tell my first year self.

The other mistake was water. I treated it like soup and added enough liquid to cover the apples, and I ended up with something closer to juice that I had to cook back down for another forty minutes. Apples are mostly water already. Trust them.

And I would skip peeling apples for a small batch entirely. If you only have three or four apples and no food mill, make crockpot apple butter instead. It is more forgiving, it cooks unattended, and a small amount of it goes much further.

Questions I get about homemade applesauce

Do I have to peel the apples?

Only if you do not have a food mill. The mill catches every bit of skin and seed for you. If you are mashing or blending instead, the skins will stay in as little flecks, which some people do not mind and some people really do.

Can I make applesauce in a slow cooker?

Yes, and it is a good option if you are not going to be standing near the stove. Quartered apples, a quarter cup of water, low for four to six hours. The texture comes out slightly softer and sweeter because of the long cook, and it is much harder to scorch.

Is homemade applesauce safe for babies?

Unsweetened applesauce with nothing added is one of the simplest first foods there is, though the timing and texture question is one for your pediatrician and not for me. What I will say is that making it myself is the reason I know exactly what is in the bowl, which was worth a lot to me in that first year of figuring out what slow living looks like with a baby.

Why did my applesauce turn brown?

Oxidation, usually from apples sitting cut on the counter too long before they hit the heat. The lemon juice helps. So does working in batches and getting the pot going while you cut the rest.

How many apples do I need?

Five pounds, which is roughly fifteen medium apples, gives you about six cups. A peck is around ten pounds. A bushel is around forty, which sounds absurd until you have a toddler who eats it daily and a freezer that you would like to be full before the first real cold.

Can I use bruised or ugly apples?

That is exactly what they are for. Cut the bad parts out and use the rest. Seconds from the orchard are cheaper and they cook down the same.

There is a specific kind of quiet that happens when the pot is going, Dewey is asleep under the table, and the whole downstairs smells like apples. I am not going to pretend the afternoon is restful, because it is not, it is work. But it is the good kind, the kind where you can see what you made at the end of it lined up on the counter.

If you make it, use three kinds of apples. That is the whole secret.